"He who guards his mouth keeps his life,
but he who opens wide his lips comes to ruin”
(Proverbs 13:3)
"This is what we speak, not in words taught us by human wisdom but in words taught by the Spirit, expressing spiritual truths in spiritual words."
(I Corinthians 2: 12-14)
Would you like to know the definition of a "fanatic"?
A fanatic is someone who won't change their mind and won't change the subject.
I've met a few in my lifetime.
But, hey...
I won't point my finger at them without the willingness to point that same finger back at me.
One-way criticism doesn't lead to dialog or discovery, so I try to remain open.
If I hit hard then I have to be willing to GET hit.
If I dole out criticism I should be prepared to take it, right?
I don't want to be a fanatic who's so stuck that I'm unwilling to hear all sides of the story.
But sometimes I DO make up my mind about things and hold steadfast to my beliefs.
Then I talk about it.
If I believe that what I'm saying can help people, I have a moral obligation to speak my truth, right?
Or should I keep a guard at my mouth and stay quiet, keep my place, cow-tow to the systems that didn't work for me because SOMEONE might be offended by my viewpoint?
Someone challenged me last night.
I was a guest speaker in a room of about 30 college students.
The host asked me to speak about motivation, specifically about behaving differently than we feel when it comes to keeping commitments.
I was supposed talk about doing the right thing vs. doing the comfortable thing.
I don't remember how 12 Step recovery came up in the conversation.
I'm openly critical of 12 Step recovery because of its failure to address the physical causes of addiction and because IT DIDN'T HELP ME.
I criticize 12 Steppers for their cult-like fanaticism.
It's wrong to tell people that they're somehow deficient if they're not willing to submit to a low-success-rate 12 Step recovery program.
Hey, I may criticize the
Overeaters Anonymous program but I'm willing to look critically at my own beliefs, too. My critical eye works both ways.
I admit,
I may be a fanatic.
I may not be willing to shut up about the things I've discovered.
I may be fanatical about the truth of my own experience.
I may be a fanatic because I DO cling to the idea that recovery does NOT have to be a lifelong, one-day-at-a-time battle of will and I REFUSE to shut up about it.
I DO believe that all the Anonymous programs need to address nutritional aspects of wellness in order to increase their odds of success.
I had no idea that this idea would be so controversial.
I thought society had moved on from the idea that 12 Step is the last hope for addiction recovery.
I know from experience that the battle of will doesn't have to be ongoing day after day.
My life is proof of that.
I got off the white sugar, white flour, processed crap foods (forcibly via my gastric bypass last August) and suddenly the battle of will became a pinkie-toe blip on my recovery radar.
It was difficult at first but now things are different.
Food no longer torments me.
I no longer binge on sugary, fatty, starchy garbage foods.
I no longer crave them.
I
really don't want them.
Really.
This past Sunday I was at a charity brunch. I pigged out on fresh pineapple, string beans, salad, a bagel (I know, I know, white flour), and coffee. It was great.
I also took lots of food home.
I had the
foresight to bring
ziplock baggies with me so I could bring food home to my friends. I must have smuggled out 5 pounds of danishes, pastries, muffins, bagels, cookies, brownies and cakes (and fruit for me :-).
I came home with my giant bag of food.
I unwrapped my booty and arranged everything, buffet-style, on 3 large dinner plates on my coffee table.
I had one bagel from the center plate and that was it.
Nothing else.
Was there a battle of will between me and the 3 plates of food?
No.
I didn't want any of the food.
For real.
I wanted my friends to enjoy themselves.
It wasn't food for me it was food for company.
I left the food out on my coffee table overnight so it would be set up for my Monday night guests.
Still, with all those carbs there for the taking I felt no temptation, no battle of will, no need to "taste" the icing off the top of anything.
No cravings.
Was it the surgery that stopped me?
Only partially.
The aversion to foods that make me feel nauseated is a huge part of this no-cravings lifestyle.
This doesn't totally get me off the hook.
I AM ABLE to eat junk food.
If I really, really want it I can eat the desserty foods.
It
is possible for me to eat a rich, chocolaty brownie or cookie or piece of cake.
If I take one tiny bite at a time I can eat it fairly comfortably.
Remember, I ate an entire piece of apple pie at the Flop House Inn (the fabulous Jefferson Hotel in Richmond, VA) one tiny bite at a time stretched out over 3 hours.
(Click here to read the story)
The gastric bypass isn't the magic bullet that made me completely immune to sugar cravings. It helped but it's not the sole reason for my transformed eating habits.
I thought I had explained all this in my talks and here in my Blog.
Was I unclear?
See, I was surprised when last night's host, without warning, put me on the spot for my criticism of 12 Step.
He claimed that it was the "most successful program in the country" and that when people fail it's because they failed to work the program NOT because the program failed the person.
I asked if he believed I was a failure.
He said he believed I was in
denial.
His belief is that once you're an addict, you're always an addict.
That even one drink (or marshmallow for the
OAers) will lead to a terrible bender/binge and that this is the truth of the
addict's existence for life.
"What's so great or new about what YOU'RE doing?" he asked.
Gee, I thought I had explained that.
He defended 12 Step programs for being oh-so-very helpful and never charging people any money. (So a program that's
free and has good intentions should be immune to criticism??)
It didn't help that the host presented his objections in a hostile, who-do-you-think-you-are tone of voice.
It wasn't even an
argument on his part. It was more of a "how dare you contradict my beliefs" kinda in-my-face scolding than an argument. I felt steamrolled and misunderstood.
I was shaking.
Tears were caught in my throat.
His hostility was so unexpected.
I tried to keep my sense of humor.
I tried to handle his objections with grace and tact.
To tell you the truth it's such a blur I don't even know if I handled it well.
I have no idea if the students could sense my anxiety.
I think I did ok but it was unnerving.
I was so tense and upset I couldn't even cry about it till this morning.
Is this what the skeptical world has in store for me?
How dare I recover once and for all.
How dare I refuse to declare myself powerless.
How dare I challenge the great 12 Step programs that have saved so many, you know, the ones who work it.
How dare I REFUSE to call myself a failure.
How dare I pursue self empowerment and the empowerment of others in a new,
vitalistic way.
"The treatment usually begins by being repeatedly told that the first step to recovery is the declaration: I am an alcoholic. For the sinner to be saved, the sinner must first admit he is a sinner. (I am not claiming that A.A. uses the word 'sin' or 'sinner' or 'grace' or that there is any official use of theological terminology.) To refuse to do so is proof the sick one is
“in denial” and without grace. The only way to prove you are not in denial is to admit you are an alcoholic:"
~ from
Skepdic.com
(Click here for the whole article)
Hey, looks like I'm not the only one who feels this way about the cult of 12 Step.
(Click here for a well-written criticism of Alcoholics/Narcotics Anonymous.)
What's so great about 12 Step?
It helps SOME folks but it didn't help me.
Why SHOULDN'T I criticize it??
I think a 10% - 25% success rate is PISS POOR!
I'm not alone.
(
Click here for an interesting website of a Rational Recovery practitioner who says,
"The worst possible way to quit something you love is one-day-at-a-time.
Stay away from recovery groups of all kinds; you can’t possibly recover there.
They’ll never let you go, and you’ll be 'in recovery' forever."
Whew.
So my ideas AREN'T so wacky after all.
There are plenty of sane, intelligent, good people out there who agree with me about the ineffectiveness of 12 Stepping and are striking out on their own to find ways to help people permanently recover and stay well FOREVER.
Thank God.
I'm a rebel but I'm onto something folks have been discovering for years.
There's nothing terribly new about what I'm saying.
I'm saying that NUTRITIONAL transformation is an essential factor in the transformation that leads to permanent recovery.
I did some Googling.
This field is full of great research and insights.
There are plenty of hard-scientists and medical practitioners as well as holistic healers who are recognizing the need for nutritional treatment in the permanent cure of addiction.
One article claims that
"nutrition is often overlooked as a necessary component of detoxification and recovery...When treatment programs utilize body-mind-spirit approaches with well-designed nutritional protocols, the successes are dynamic."
Look, I know I'm getting very
linky in this post. I just want to show you that I'm not trying to re-invent the wheel here.
I just want to indicate that nutritional support for curing addiction is out there for you and me to discover.
I don't even
have to read and research this topic thoroughly (yet) to convince myself because my progress is evidence enough for me that I'm doing the right thing.
When it's time for my book on the topic, then I'll do the thorough research.
For now I'm going to live my life as evidence that I'm on the right path.
As for my
confrontive critics, I'll just have to keep sparring with them till I toughen up.
I will not be intimidated into silence.
*Movement for the
UnMotivated*
Doing one good thing for yourself makes room for you to do more.
Even washing ONE piece of your
handwashable clothing and letting it drip dry makes you feel good.
Look at that ____ hanging there. YOU washed it!
YOU took care of yourself.
Pat yourself on the back.
You've just made room in your life to do something else for your own self-care.
Yesterday's Weight: 254
Today's Blood Sugar: 204
Click here to leave me a comment!